Jamie Redman: OP_Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate

tokenization tokeda technology study steve-shadders shammah-chancellor scripting-language representative-assets proposal op-group omni nchain n-technology metadata jonald-fyookball jason-cox ethereum eth emil-oldenburg electron-cash developers daniel-connolly couterparty colored-coins bitcoin-unlimited bitcoin-abc andrew-stone andrea-suisani amaury-sechet

OP_Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate

This week Andrew Stone, the lead developer of Bitcoin Unlimited (BU), published a 42-page paper that details the evolution of the original OP_Group proposal. OP_Group is a single OP_Code that could be added to the Bitcoin Cash (BCH) network’s scripting language in order to effectively create colored coins. However, unlike other representative token protocols like Omni or Counterparty, if the OP_Group protocol was used it would require a protocol change, and miners would validate colored coins within the confirmation of normal transactions.

Also read: Bitcoin ABC Developers Publish Bitcoin Cash Upgrade Timeline

Bitcoin Unlimited’s Andrew Stone Publishes the Evolution of the OP_Group Proposal

OP_Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin DebateEarlier this week, news.Bitcoin.com reported on the upcoming Bitcoin Cash (BCH) network upgrade that will take place in November. The Bitcoin ABC development team revealed a timeline of certain goals like building and polishing the 0.18 ABC software and launching the client by October 15. However, the developers didn’t detail exactly what will be included in the next upgrade.

A few days later, Bitcoin Unlimited’s Andrew Stone published the evolution of the OP_Group proposal which is an implementation that could effectively add a plethora of features like representative tokens. Although, the proposal does not have broad consensus just yet as other developers have alternative ideas for colored coin creation and some think the OP_Group may be risky.

OP_Group Could Extend the BCH Script Language to Allow a Plethora of Features

Bitcoin Unlimited’s lead developer Andrew Stone believes the community should listen and participate in the colored coin discussion. Alongside publishing the 42-page document, Stone has also left a video of the discussion that features the BCH ‘Token Work Group.’ The group consists of developers such as BU’s Stone, and Andrea Suisani, Bitcoin.com’s Emil Oldenburg, Bitcoin ABC’s Amaury Sechet, Shammah Chancellor, Jason Cox, Nchain’s Steve Shadders, Daniel Connolly, and the Electron Cash developer Jonald Fyookball.      

“This is the evolution of the original OP_Group proposal — It’s no longer an opcode, so name change,” Stone explains. “The document is a bit long but that’s because it lays out a roadmap to extending the BCH script language to allow some pretty awesome features but at the same time preserving bitcoin script’s efficiency. For example, in the end, I show how you could create a bet with OP_Datasigverify, and then tokenize the outcome of that bet to create a prediction market.”

I strongly urge people to listen carefully to this discussion, even if you are not that interested in tokens, as it shows pretty clear philosophical differences that will likely influence BCH development for years to come.

OP_Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate

Some Proponents Disagree With OP_Group and They Believe Tokenization Can Happen Without Making BCH Consensus Changes

Basically, Bitcoin Cash proponents who disagree with Stone’s OP_Group proposal favor tokenization ideas that don’t require a change to the BCH codebase. Further, some people believe it would be safer to use protocols that work outside the main chain and operate like a sidechain or something similar. Another idea being discussed is ‘Tokeda,’ a token-driven metadata proposal written by Joannes Vermorel. The 31-page Tokeda proposal is also an early draft last updated, March 30, 2018, that is incomplete, explains Vermorel.

Tokeda addresses both the challenge of viably preserving an unbounded amount of metadata without endangering Bitcoin itself and the challenge of introducing tokens within Bitcoin by weaving the two problems through aligned economic incentives,” explains Vermorel’s paper.

Tokeda is compatible with stateless wallets (which include SPV wallets) and requires no consensus change. As a token scheme, Tokeda relies on a trust-but-verify security model centered around the issuer.

Vermorel believes the BCH community needs to learn from the scaling issues the Ethereum network faces by making tokenization simpler.

“Since, it is now clear that tokenization does not require a change of the base protocol, it’s up to the market to deliver solutions, based on Tokeda, or anything deemed superior,” Vermorel details. “If there is one lesson to be learned from ETH it’s violating the locality principle in your design kills the scalability.”

A Matter of Opinion and the Benefits of a Universal Method that Creates Permissionless Tokens

Many others have stated their opinions concerning Stone’s OP_Group proposal and Vermorel’s Tokeda. Following Stone’s published paper, Jonald Fyookball revealed some of his subjective valuations in a paper called ‘Thoughts on Tokens for BCH.’

“Whether or not we should change the BCH protocol to add GROUP is a risk/reward question and a matter of opinion,” Fyookball states. “Part of what made ERC20 so successful is how easy it is for anyone to create and issue a token, and for the ecosystem to support it. The BCH protocol already allows colored coins but no one uses it because the ecosystem doesn’t support it.”

In any case, I believe BCH would greatly benefit from a universal method for doing SPV-friendly, permissionless tokens.

What do you think about the OP_Group proposal described by BU’s Andrew Stone? What do you think about other ideas like Joannes Vermorel’s Tokeda? Let us know your thoughts on this subject in the comment section below.

Images via Shutterstock, Pixabay, and Youtube.

Want to create your own secure cold storage paper wallet? Check our tools section.

The post OP_Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate appeared first on Bitcoin News.

Original article was created by: Jamie Redman at news.bitcoin.com

Disclaimer: This article should not be taken as, and is not intended to provide, investment advice. Please conduct your own thorough research before investing in any cryptocurrency or ICO.

Interested in Cryptocurrencies and ICO's?

Follow our telegram channel for daily cryptomarket reports!

Join @cointrends

Related Articles

pubDate Newsline
1 month ago Benefits of Blockchain to Any Industry
1 month ago 5 Benefits of Crowdfunding for Nonprofits in 2018
1 month ago BANKEX Monthly Update: September 2018
1 month ago Blocktix Dev Update Q3
1 month ago SV Pool Mines Its First Block as November’s Bitcoin Cash Fork Approaches
1 month ago Programmable Money: Bitcoin Cash Community Debates Oracle Driven Upgrade
1 month ago SV Pool Mines Its First Block as November’s Bitcoin Cash Fork Approaches
1 month ago Programmable Money: Bitcoin Cash Community Debates Oracle Driven Upgrade
1 month ago The world’s first tokenized real estate fund
1 month ago Crowd Machine joins the OECD Blockchain Policy Forum
1 month ago Frictionless Commerce: A Story of How Easy It Is to Start Accepting Bitcoin Cash
1 month ago HOQU merchant app beta-version: explore it!
1 month ago Chrome Extensions Will Soon Protect Against Miners and Hackers
1 month ago Crypto-Community Debates Bitcoin Core Bug and a ‘Forced Upgrade’
1 month ago Chrome Extensions Will Soon Protect Against Miners and Hackers
1 month ago How to Set up a Bitcoin Paper Wallet
1 month ago Chopsticks API Gives BCH Application Developers Options During a Contentious Fork
1 month ago Programmable Money: Bitcoin Cash Community Debates Oracle Driven Upgrade
1 month ago Russian Crypto Groups in Telegram Increase Membership Despite Ban
1 month ago The Daily: Speculators and Investors Hodl, Venezuelans Send Crypto With SMS
1 month ago The Bitcoin Files Protocol Provides a BCH Secured File Storage System
2 months ago Op-ed: The Case for Adding CTOR to Bitcoin Cash in November
1 month ago Programmable Money: Bitcoin Cash Community Debates Oracle Driven Upgrade
2 months ago Bitcoin Cash Hard Fork Debate Reconvenes After the Stress Test
2 months ago Bitmain’s $50M ‘Permissionless Ventures’ First Project: BCH Dev Con
2 months ago Bitcoin Cash Hard Fork Debate Reconvenes After the Stress Test
3 months ago The Bitcoin Cash Pre-Consensus Debate Continues
2 months ago Bitcoin Cash Upgrade Debate: One CPU Equals One Vote
3 months ago Nchain Plans to Launch a BCH Full Node Client Called ‘Bitcoin SV’
2 months ago Simple Ledger Token Creation Platform Launches on the BCH Network
2 months ago Create Your Own Crypto Token With BCH-Powered Cryptonize It
4 months ago No Matter How You Slice It — Token Assets Are Coming to Bitcoin Cash
3 months ago November BCH Upgrade Discussion Heats Up After Bitcoin SV Full Node Announcement
3 months ago Nchain Plans to Launch a BCH Full Node Client Called ‘Bitcoin SV’
4 months ago No Matter How You Slice It — Token Assets Are Coming to Bitcoin Cash
4 months ago No Matter How You Slice It — Token Assets Are Coming to Bitcoin Cash
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate
4 months ago Group or Tokeda? A Look at the BCH Color Coin Debate

Stay on top of Altcoins and ICO trends.

Subscribe to our free Weekly Cryptomarket report

Delivered once a week, strongly to your inbox.

Subscribe to our mailing list
October 12, 2018

Win $100 of Bitcoin Cash in Bitcoin.com’s Paper Wallet Design Contest

Over the next few weeks, Bitcoin.com is hosting a paper wallet design contest to create a beautiful cold storage visual graphic for bitcoin enthusiasts around the world. The competition is open to everyone and the winning entry will receive $100 worth of bitcoin cash. Also Read: Bitcoin.com...

From: Bitcoin.com

The Daily: Kanye Teaches Opsec, Crypto Foes Join Forces

The last 24 hours has been one of those all-too-rare periods in which the cryptosphere unites against a shared enemy. We’ll detail who in The Daily, right after we’ve discussed blockchain spam, Blockfolio’s new funding round, and how we learned an opsec lesson from Kanye West. Also...

From: Kai Sedgwick

US Court Issues Emergency Order Halting a Planned Initial Coin Offering

An American court has put a stop to an initial coin offering (ICO) by a company claiming to offer “the first licensed and regulated tokenized crypto currency exchange & index fund based in the US.” The ICO promoters even invented their own regulatory authority, which seems to...

From: Avi Mizrahi

Largest South Korean Exchange Launches Crypto Market Indices

The largest crypto exchange in South Korea by trading volume, Bithumb, has launched two cryptocurrency market indices. One tracks all coins listed on the exchange while the other tracks only altcoins. Meanwhile, Upbit, the country’s largest crypto exchange by the number of coins listed, has...

From: Kevin Helms

Funny New Advert Shows Bitcoin Is on Google’s Mind

Google, which currently sits on the fence with regard to cryptocurrency, took an opportunity to throw shade at digital coins like bitcoin core and bitcoin cash during an advert for its new call-screening feature. In the minute-long segment, popular comedians dressed as Google employees mock...

From: Jeffrey Gogo

Facebook Purge Continues: 559 Pages, 251 Accounts Removed Ahead of US Elections

Facebook’s Nathaniel Gleicher, Head of Cybersecurity Policy, and Oscar Rodriguez, Product Manager, announced that “Today, we’re removing 559 pages and 251 accounts that have consistently broken our rules against spam and coordinated inauthentic behavior.” It is another decision to purge...

From: C. Edward Kelso
Upcoming ICO's
This week overview
Token Name Starts
CDRX (CDRX) logo CDRX (CDRX) 1 days
SkyMap (SKYM) logo SkyMap (SKYM) 1 days
Aditus (ADI) logo Aditus (ADI) 2 days
PlayChip (PLA) logo PlayChip (PLA) 3 days
Stem Cell (SCIA) logo Stem Cell (SCIA) 3 days
Nodvix (NVDX) logo Nodvix (NVDX) 4 days
B21 (B21) logo B21 (B21) 5 days
Coingrid (CGT) logo Coingrid (CGT) 5 days
Empleos (PLEO) logo Empleos (PLEO) 7 days
Cryptocurrency rates
*Last hour average price&change
Coin Name Price Hour
Bitcoin logo BTC $5610.24428205 -0.03%
Ripple logo XRP $0.5061885578 -1.49%
Ethereum logo ETH $176.272310756 -0.41%
Bitcoin Cash logo BCH $380.780862866 -3.51%
Stellar logo XLM $0.2502607033 0.03%
EOS logo EOS $4.6124946577 -0.49%
Litecoin logo LTC $42.5886274204 -0.51%
Tether logo USDT $0.9874324497 -0.03%
Cardano logo ADA $0.0618950988 -0.53%
Monero logo XMR $89.4743906935 -1%
Tronix logo TRX $0.0190612693 -0.09%
IOTA logo IOT $0.4170974521 -0.33%